I have been away from writing here for a while, during my journey from California to Michigan. In that time, the world went through an Indigo Point—an inflection point of profound significance—in AI
As a conservative university professor, I have to say I have been concerned about where ChatGPT will take education. Your three scenarios are very likely outcomes.
A. I can definitely see this happening, and I know it is one of the biggest concerns many of my colleagues have in regards to "AI" in education right now. That said, students already try to cheat, and I don't doubt many have succeeded. I've already been concerned about those that pass without truly knowing the material and how that dilutes the value of education.
B. This is also likely to happen in many cases, especially for students who don't want to do A and truly want to learn. And many I have taught truly do. Having been thru a PhD program, I can say that we're not taught to teach. We're taught to do academic research (which is a frustration of mine and a topic for another day). As such, many aren't the most proficient educators.
C: I'm curious about this one. I could see some administratiors doing this...let's hope not.
AI will likely have a strong impact on education, but that assumes higher education continues. Given that many conservative voices trash higher Ed in general, it may not matter for long if they have their way in abolishing universities.
(On a side note, enjoy Michigan. I grew up in southwest Michigan about 1.25 miles from Lake Michigan. It's a beautiful state. I moved away for the PhD and subsequent teaching job, but I do miss it there!!)
Enjoyed reading this post, congratulations on the new chapter filled with love and hope. My husband and I came to each other at a time we both thought something this comforting and comfortable was beyond our reach, and 15 years later we continue to grow in love.
One phrase caught me, as it echoes something an acquaintance said to me some months ago: “20 years of drought”; aforementioned acquaintance said “30 years”. I didn’t argue, she was born/raised in SoCal. But I must ask if you might expand on your comment, at some point in time.
I’ve been in CA (Bay Area, North Bay, and now very rural area of Riverside County) for ~34 years. Arrived as one drought ended and have witnessed the dry-wet cycles all these years. In SoCal, we just had our third “super-bloom” in 8 years. In 2017, the major artery across the North Bay from the East Bay was closed in February due to flooding, and that same fall my former home of Santa Rosa was severely damaged as a result of fires being spread at unimaginable speed as they were whipped by the dry Diablo offshore windstorm.
I can recall several drought-ending or drought-relieving seasons over the last three decades. I’m fully aware that the several regions in this state experience different levels of this cycle at different times - e.g., SoCal being dry when northern half of state is soaked and vice versa. Reading history of settlers moving to the state across the deserts and mountains confirms the cyclical nature of wet-dry conditions. Devin Nunes elaborates on how the aqueduct/watery storage infrastructure in the state was designed for 5-year droughts.
I have a hard time reconciling my observations with statements about 20- or 30-year droughts. Now you’re in Michigan where this isn’t an issue; and your writing is going to focus on an incredibly important juncture in our world - which I welcome. So this topic may remain in your rearview mirror, and I would understand.
Last note: cgg, we understand your situation all too well! Do we stay for the madness, and where could we go where it is unlikely to reach us?
I am envious of the fact that you have perspective. I am in CA ( SF Bay Area) and for a long time, even pre-CV, I have felt that I did not have an adequate picture of what was really going on in society. I am not in a position to move due to elderly parents on both sides, but the atmosphere here is very heavy and there are days where everyone in my family has had a conversation about leaving. It makes me very sad though because my family has been living here for four generations now, which is very rare in this area. I feel torn about wanting to leave my home and staying to fight for it.
The other thing is in part because we have been here for so long - where do we go? In some respects, I feel a move just to a different county would be a lift, but CA government is massively failing its citizens. It feels like it would just be a postponement.
Change is a fact of life. You so obviously understand this and the role history plays in change! I’m not a technological expert, using the tech to access information only. Your love of history shines in this post, as does the love for your daughters and your ‘new’ family. You have read much of the same history as I. You’ve used it to bring your daughters up to speed so they, too, can adapt to the massive changes you’ve described. Leaving CA for the beautiful ‘wilds’ of MI has definitely been influential to your (and your new family’s) future and you described the wonderful creation God made for us. The natural apolitical world is a breath of fresh air in this controlled world. I am so thankful you’re back in an area where the intended beauty for mankind is displayed. I don’t know enough to ascertain the future of AI, but I know God shines through His creation and it was created for us. God bless you and your new family. Your God-given gifts in this war are much appreciated!
Congrats on achieving your move to a beautiful new world for you and your family. I love the sunshine on your books pic. It looks like "home". Winter sun pours into my home right now ..... sometimes I catch a snooze in it. Thankyou for your words, your insight and your saneness.
Congratulations on your transition!
As a conservative university professor, I have to say I have been concerned about where ChatGPT will take education. Your three scenarios are very likely outcomes.
A. I can definitely see this happening, and I know it is one of the biggest concerns many of my colleagues have in regards to "AI" in education right now. That said, students already try to cheat, and I don't doubt many have succeeded. I've already been concerned about those that pass without truly knowing the material and how that dilutes the value of education.
B. This is also likely to happen in many cases, especially for students who don't want to do A and truly want to learn. And many I have taught truly do. Having been thru a PhD program, I can say that we're not taught to teach. We're taught to do academic research (which is a frustration of mine and a topic for another day). As such, many aren't the most proficient educators.
C: I'm curious about this one. I could see some administratiors doing this...let's hope not.
AI will likely have a strong impact on education, but that assumes higher education continues. Given that many conservative voices trash higher Ed in general, it may not matter for long if they have their way in abolishing universities.
(On a side note, enjoy Michigan. I grew up in southwest Michigan about 1.25 miles from Lake Michigan. It's a beautiful state. I moved away for the PhD and subsequent teaching job, but I do miss it there!!)
You're welcome. Thanks for the article. I look forward to reading more of your thoughts on the topic as you post more articles!
thank you for that thoughtful comment.
Enjoyed reading this post, congratulations on the new chapter filled with love and hope. My husband and I came to each other at a time we both thought something this comforting and comfortable was beyond our reach, and 15 years later we continue to grow in love.
One phrase caught me, as it echoes something an acquaintance said to me some months ago: “20 years of drought”; aforementioned acquaintance said “30 years”. I didn’t argue, she was born/raised in SoCal. But I must ask if you might expand on your comment, at some point in time.
I’ve been in CA (Bay Area, North Bay, and now very rural area of Riverside County) for ~34 years. Arrived as one drought ended and have witnessed the dry-wet cycles all these years. In SoCal, we just had our third “super-bloom” in 8 years. In 2017, the major artery across the North Bay from the East Bay was closed in February due to flooding, and that same fall my former home of Santa Rosa was severely damaged as a result of fires being spread at unimaginable speed as they were whipped by the dry Diablo offshore windstorm.
I can recall several drought-ending or drought-relieving seasons over the last three decades. I’m fully aware that the several regions in this state experience different levels of this cycle at different times - e.g., SoCal being dry when northern half of state is soaked and vice versa. Reading history of settlers moving to the state across the deserts and mountains confirms the cyclical nature of wet-dry conditions. Devin Nunes elaborates on how the aqueduct/watery storage infrastructure in the state was designed for 5-year droughts.
I have a hard time reconciling my observations with statements about 20- or 30-year droughts. Now you’re in Michigan where this isn’t an issue; and your writing is going to focus on an incredibly important juncture in our world - which I welcome. So this topic may remain in your rearview mirror, and I would understand.
Last note: cgg, we understand your situation all too well! Do we stay for the madness, and where could we go where it is unlikely to reach us?
Glad you made it to tranquility Eric. I look forward to your insight once again.
Looking forward to see where this goes.
I am envious of the fact that you have perspective. I am in CA ( SF Bay Area) and for a long time, even pre-CV, I have felt that I did not have an adequate picture of what was really going on in society. I am not in a position to move due to elderly parents on both sides, but the atmosphere here is very heavy and there are days where everyone in my family has had a conversation about leaving. It makes me very sad though because my family has been living here for four generations now, which is very rare in this area. I feel torn about wanting to leave my home and staying to fight for it.
The other thing is in part because we have been here for so long - where do we go? In some respects, I feel a move just to a different county would be a lift, but CA government is massively failing its citizens. It feels like it would just be a postponement.
Congratulations on taking the plunge!
Change is a fact of life. You so obviously understand this and the role history plays in change! I’m not a technological expert, using the tech to access information only. Your love of history shines in this post, as does the love for your daughters and your ‘new’ family. You have read much of the same history as I. You’ve used it to bring your daughters up to speed so they, too, can adapt to the massive changes you’ve described. Leaving CA for the beautiful ‘wilds’ of MI has definitely been influential to your (and your new family’s) future and you described the wonderful creation God made for us. The natural apolitical world is a breath of fresh air in this controlled world. I am so thankful you’re back in an area where the intended beauty for mankind is displayed. I don’t know enough to ascertain the future of AI, but I know God shines through His creation and it was created for us. God bless you and your new family. Your God-given gifts in this war are much appreciated!
🙏
Such a beautiful response!
Congrats on achieving your move to a beautiful new world for you and your family. I love the sunshine on your books pic. It looks like "home". Winter sun pours into my home right now ..... sometimes I catch a snooze in it. Thankyou for your words, your insight and your saneness.
Thank you for your steady guidance and congratulations on your beautiful new home.
You wrote the words that I’ve been saying to myself this week.
From the 40,000 foot view, we should all see how the evil bastards are being vanquished, slowly.
We all just need to pray that HE will bring our world back to sanity and sanctity. HE WILL.
IMO, between now and then, we will be faced with some terrifying scenarios around the world, so patriots must be vigilant and stay in faith.
Thank you once again for bringing clarity and optimism to this very confusing and dangerous situation.
🙏🇺🇸🙏
This is a very timely and significant article! Looking forward to the next articles of the series. What a time to be alive!